
John sees and holds the harmonica for the first time.

John stands whilst the principal is seated.
The harmonica introduces us to John's passion for music. As this is an autobiographical film of someone so widely famous, the director had to show us in some way how far along John was with his musical interest and the harmonica shows this. From the dialogue within the scene it seems that John has not ever owned a harmonica (let alone any other instrument) but regardless, he is still very passionate about music (Later on John gets an acoustic guitar, and this becomes his new focus. After that John gets an electric guitar. It seems that as his musical talent increases, so does the quality of the instruments he plays). His uncle tells him that John will have his "first lesson, front room, eight o'clock tonight". The scene of the lesson is the first scene after the opening, and also the scene in which Uncle George suffers a liver hemorrhage and dies. As a result the harmonica becomes more important to John, and a symbol of the only father figure John had in his life. The loss of George is difficult for John as his death seems to change everything; he is left to juggle his relationship with Aunt Mimi and his real mother(whom he had never met before the funeral), Julia. Blocking is used well to show the quietly arrogant attitude John has towards himself. John stands, upright and confident in front of the principals desk while the principal stays seated. This shows the status John believes exists between them, that regardless of titles, John is in control of the situation. This sets the viewer up well for the John portrayed in the film. Although John was in some cases seen as arrogant (ie "Bigger then Jesus") the character in the film is younger, and therefore more fearless and up himself. Later in the film when John is introduced to Paul (Mccartney, who of course would later become a member of The Beatles) John blatantly believes he is better then him in every way. After Paul shows his obvious talent, John still tells him no to joining the band. This is a rather unsurprising act of pride, and John seems to later only invite him into the band after a friend tells him "I'd rather him in our band then anyone else's".
Nowhere Boy used Mis-en-scene similarly as traditional forms of drama did such as Melodrama and Comedia de'llarte, although Nowhere Boy used the same conventions in a much more subtle, less amusing way. In melodrama, status was often shown by Kings and other forms of hierarchy often walking in tip toes, or others simply bowing or sitting lower then them. This is much the same as this situation of the film, yet with a more unobvious meaning behind it. In Comedia de'llarte the character Pantalone carries around a bag of money which he is never caught without. It is a symbol of something important to him; and an important aspect of the character. The harmonica, for John symbolises much the same; it's important to him and shows an important aspect to his character. The director seems to have used very traditional forms of drama to get complex points across to viewers.
Well done! You have described some examples and the technique well and also explained how the technique is used to show you something about the characters. Then you have analysed by including your own outside knowledge about John Lennon, and even though I think you might be reaching a bit by making a comparison between Pantalone and John Lennon, it's great to see you tying in the use of mise-en-scene to a greater tradition of symbolism in the arts to create meaning for the viewer! :)
ReplyDelete